Menopause and joints

Squat alternatives for bad knees: what knee arthritis research says about leg strength

No guideline says to stop squatting. Here is what knee arthritis research supports, why heavier isn't always better, and knee-friendly options to try.

★★★★★ 5.0 on GoogleFrom $14 a sessionFirst session free, no cardHSA / FSA eligible

If your knees ache on the stairs or when you get up from a low couch, you may have been told to "stop squatting." The research tells a different story. Strong legs and hips are part of every major plan for knee arthritis, and there are many ways to train them without forcing a deep, painful squat. HipTrain wrote this page. We're a live online personal training service, not a clinic, so this is educational information, not medical advice. Please talk with your doctor about your knees before you start, especially if a knee is swollen, gives way or was recently injured.

The short answer

Exercise is a strongly recommended part of managing knee osteoarthritis. The 2019 American College of Rheumatology and Arthritis Foundation guideline makes a strong recommendation for exercise and for tai chi. A Cochrane review found exercise reduced knee pain and improved function to a moderate degree. Adding resistance exercise for the hips to quad strengthening improved pain and function in a 2020 review. And in the 2021 START trial, heavy strength training was no better for knee pain than lighter training. So the goal is not to avoid leg work. It is to pick a load and a range that your knees tolerate.

What the guidelines and trials say

Exercise is a strong recommendation. The ACR and Arthritis Foundation 2019 guideline for osteoarthritis of the hand, hip and knee made strong recommendations for exercise, weight loss for people who are overweight, self-management programs, tai chi and cane use. It made conditional recommendations for balance exercises and yoga.

The effect is real but moderate. A 2015 Cochrane review by Fransen and colleagues pooled trials of exercise for knee osteoarthritis. Exercise reduced pain by about 12 points on a 100-point scale and improved physical function by about 10 points, right after treatment. The benefit was sustained for at least 2 to 6 months after formal treatment ended.

Heavier isn't better for pain. The START trial, published in JAMA in 2021, followed 377 adults aged 50 and older with knee osteoarthritis for 18 months. High-intensity strength training did not significantly reduce knee pain compared with low-intensity strength training or an attention control group. The high-intensity group also had more minor (nonserious) side effects: 53 compared with 30 in the low-intensity group and 4 in the control group.

Hips matter too. A 2020 review by Hislop and colleagues in the British Journal of Sports Medicine found that adding hip strengthening to quad strengthening improved walking in people with knee osteoarthritis, and that adding resistance-type hip exercises improved pain and function. When all types of hip exercise were pooled together, the pain difference was not significant, so the resistance part seems to matter.

Walking is fine. The U.S. Physical Activity Guidelines say walking up to 10,000 steps a day does not appear to worsen osteoarthritis of the knee, and that, when done safely, physical activity does not make the disease or the pain worse.

So are squats bad for your knees?

No guideline we found bans squats. The Physical Activity Guidelines say health care professionals typically counsel people with osteoarthritis to choose activities that are low impact, not painful and have low risk of joint injury. For many people, that means changing how deep, how fast or how heavy the squat is, rather than dropping it. Getting up from a chair is a squat, after all, and you need it every day.

Knee-friendly squat alternatives to ask about

The specific exercises below are common coaching choices, not guideline text. They aim to train the same muscles (quads, hamstrings and hips) with a range and load your knees can handle. Go over them with your doctor or physical therapist.

OptionWhat it trainsKnee-friendly cue
Sit-to-stand from a firm chairQuads and glutes, the everyday squatUse a higher seat or a cushion to shorten the range
Box squat to a chairQuads and glutes with a set depthTouch the seat lightly, then stand; no dropping
Partial-range squatQuads and glutesStop above the point where the knee complains
Glute bridgeGlutes and hamstrings with no knee loadFeet flat, lift from the hips, ribs down
Side-lying leg raise or band side stepHip abductors on the side of the hipSlow, toes forward, small range
Seated knee extension with a bandQuads in isolationStraighten slowly, pause, lower slowly
Standing hamstring curl with a bandHamstringsHold a counter, keep the thigh still
Low step-upQuads, glutes and balanceStart with a step a few inches high; whole foot on the step

A simple way to progress

  1. Find your pain-free range for each move. Mild effort is fine; sharp or rising knee pain is a sign to change the move.
  2. Train twice a week. Pick four or five moves from the table and do two sets each.
  3. Add reps before load. When 12 easy reps feel comfortable, add a band or a light weight, or go a little deeper.
  4. Check the next day. If your knee is more swollen or sore 24 hours later, back off a step.
  5. Keep walking on other days, at a pace your knees tolerate.

For more on keeping hips strong, see hip stiffness and glute strength.

How a live coach helps

Knee-friendly training is mostly about small adjustments: seat height, how far the knee travels, where your weight sits on the foot. Those are hard to judge alone. On HipTrain, a certified coach watches your form live on camera and adapts each move within the limits your doctor sets, so you train your legs instead of avoiding them. You keep the same coach every session, and we rematch you if it's not a fit. Plans start at $59.99 a month for one 30-minute session a week, about $14 a session, or $109.99 for one 60-minute session a week, about $25 a session. Your first session is free with no credit card, and HipTrain is HSA / FSA eligible through Truemed for people who qualify.

Where HipTrain isn't the right fit: a recent knee injury, surgery or a knee that locks or gives way should go to your doctor and a physical therapist first.

Questions

Should I stop squatting if I have knee arthritis?

Not necessarily. Arthritis guidelines strongly recommend exercise for knee osteoarthritis, and none we found bans squats. Many people use a shorter range, a higher seat or lighter load. Ask your doctor what fits your knees.

What can I do instead of squats for bad knees?

Common options include sit-to-stands from a higher chair, box squats, glute bridges, side-lying leg raises, band knee extensions and low step-ups. A 2020 review found that adding resistance hip exercises to quad work improved pain and function.

Do I need to lift heavy to help my knees?

The START trial found high-intensity strength training was no better than low-intensity training for knee pain at 18 months, and it had more minor side effects. Moderate, consistent work is a reasonable place to start.

Is walking bad for knee arthritis?

The U.S. Physical Activity Guidelines say walking up to 10,000 steps a day does not appear to worsen knee osteoarthritis. Build up gradually and talk with your doctor if pain increases.

Want a coach to adjust every rep for your knees? Try your first HipTrain session free. No credit card needed.

We checked these guidelines and trials in November 2026. Research changes, so confirm your plan with your doctor. More guides in our menopause and joints hub, and see our chair exercises guide.

Sources

Skip to content
Your first session is free. No card needed.
From $14 a session
Try For Free